The humanitarian views expressed by the speakers on the recent Habonim Zoom symposium were evident from their sympathy for the plight of Palestinians and Jews. Clearly, a peaceful settlement of the conflict is crucial to both. For this reason, the ideas expressed in the symposium are important for being positive and hopeful for the future.
However, the approach presented for ending the conflict, involving conciliation, mutual respect, building trust, and acceptance of ‘the other,’ provided no guide to the nature of the problem or its magnitude. Nor did it show that the suggested measures were capable of solving it. It simply assumed it.
This double weakness resulted in a disastrous mismatch between the real nature of the conflict and the suggestions for its resolution. Consequently, the suggested measures employed a back-to-front perspective as if the conflict were essentially both simple and solvable in principle, rather than a clash of incompatible interests.
Reconciliation, trust & incompatible interests
Recall that the war against IRA terrorism was not ended by reconciliation and trust. A major factor was that half its members were in jail or cemeteries. The other half was riddled with informers and British agents. Consequently, the IRA effectively surrendered and abandoned its attempt to bomb Northern Ireland into Eire.
Likewise, the war against Imperial Japan was not ended by even a grain of reconciliation and trust. Nor was the war against the Confederacy in North America. Nor was it possible to end the war against the Nazis this way. The reason is simple. Nazi domination of Europe was incompatible with a Europe free of Nazi domination.
In such cases, dialogue and reconciliation did not produce peace, they were its consequence. Yet lacking any analysis of Palestinian aspirations and the nature of the conflict, this was completely missed by the speakers. Palestinians were seen only as suffering victims. This astonishing lack of due diligence provided no hint of implacable enmity to the existence of Israel. For those who doubt this, consider the following.
What are Palestinian aspirations?
Although the semi-diplomatic recognition of Israel by the Palestinian Authority is often claimed as signaling Palestinian acceptance of Israel, the PA refuses to accept Israel as a Jewish nation-state with a right to exist. That is, insofar as it considers Israel a state, it is not accepted as Jewish, and insofar as it is Jewish, it is not accepted as a state.
Instead, Israel is derisively dismissed as the Zionist Entity with a limited life – exactly as described in the manifesto of the Palestinian Authority, the Palestinian National Charter (PNC) 1968. Openly and explicitly, this advocates the destruction of Israel.
Promoting the elimination of Israel
Reinforced every day by the main PA newspaper, Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, (The New Life) this aim dominates PA ideology, unites its various factions, and saturates the statements of its leaders. The PA and its constituent parts live and breathe the elimination of Israel. Consequently, the PA:
- Refuses a two-state solution as an end to the conflict.
- Claims all the territory of the British Mandate for Palestine. That is, from the river-to-the-sea, inclusive of the territory currently recognized internationally as Israel.
- Devotes tremendous efforts and resources to incite and reward murderous attacks on Israeli Jews.
- Devotes zero effort with its citizens to promote a peaceful, win-win solution.
In reality there is no Palestinian body with any political weight, with any social weight, with any economic weight, with any numerical weight, with any religious weight, or with any military weight that sees the conflict differently.
Reinforcing the Palestinian aim
Armed with toy guns and military-style uniforms, children are ‘educated’ that the murder of Jews is a divine duty. Summer camps are named after those who murder Jews. Sports events and teams are named after those who murder Jews. City squares and buildings are named after those who murder Jews. Eulogies glorify those who murder Jews. Speeches and broadcasts inciting anti-Israel and anti-Jewish violence are endemic.
Endlessly promoted in the mosques, educational system, and media, the aim of eliminating Israel is the glue that holds the different Palestinian factions together. No other sentiment is expressed except hatred of Israel and nonstop calls for its destruction. This is why the ‘West Bank’ is festooned with posters, banners, maps, wall plaques, murals, monuments, and other such material depicting only ‘Palestine.’ Signs expressing a desire for peace with Israel are entirely absent.
The Palestinian way
In sum, Palestinian-governed areas are saturated in a political-religious culture that neither respects nor seeks conciliation with the ‘other’. It is impossible in these areas to openly and safely advocate and organize in favor of acceptance of a Jewish state or “normalization” with it.
Such Palestinian hatred of Israel and Jews is painful and alarming – well beyond how we believe that anyone in their right mind would behave. Yet, despite stretching back well before the creation of modern Israel, these attitudes are often politely ‘forgotten’.
Those Palestinians who disagree face denunciation, punishment, or worse. They tell a similar story of a brutal culture fixated on hatred, envy, the belief in the righteousness of collective suffering and victimhood. Unsurprisingly, their ‘heresy’ can only be publicly expressed from elsewhere.
The Palestinian solution
All this poses a BIG problem for the belief that a Palestinian state alongside Israel is an equitable solution to the conflict. This assumes that the conflict is a land dispute between two national movements. If mutually agreed, this characterization could indeed provide a logical, moral, and political basis for dividing the territory into 2 states. Yet even a cursory examination of Palestinian intentions reveals that they reject this assumption.
Instead, they claim that Jews are not a ‘people’ but a religious community only, with no entitlement to independent national rights. The PA also asserts the bizarre notion that Jews have no religious or historical connection to the region (Article 20, PNC, 1968).
For Palestinians, the issue is a question of supremacy and identity. This is why they reject 2-states as reasonable or equitable. It is why they have consistently refused solutions on its basis both before and after the creation of Israel. It is why they routinely claim the whole territory of Mandatory Palestine and refuse to accept the legitimacy of a Jewish state on any part of it.
The real nature of the conflict
In sum, the essence of the conflict is that the PA aims to eradicate Israel. Naturally, Israel does not want to be eradicated. As these aims are mutually incompatible, they leave no middle ground for compromise. Perpetual conflict is guaranteed.
Therefore, a successful 2-state solution requires the Palestinians to abandon this aim. Distressingly, this was entirely absent from the speakers. Nor was there any hint of how they intend to “respect” the Palestinian aim of destroying Israel or how to “reconcile” this with the survival of Israel.
Consequently, with a conception of the conflict that fails to identify its eliminationist core, it is not surprising that this led to hopelessly inadequate ideas for solving it. Recall that unlike the PA, the IRA never aimed to destroy Britain. Nor did the Mau-Mau. Nor did the Viet Minh or FLN aim to destroy France. Yet even in these cases, respect and conciliation came as a result of the end of the conflict.
The upshot is this: how is it possible to achieve peace and reconciliation with those who intend to destroy Israel? Likewise, how can a state intent on destroying another state possibly conform to international law? How can a state intent on destroying another state produce regional peace and security? And how can those who aim to annihilate Israel ever be trusted?
The real political solution
Probably most Palestinians hope to have a peaceful, safe, and prosperous life. The snag is that in also hoping to destroy Israel, they destroy the prospects for this aspiration. The one excludes the other. Their aim of eliminating Israel is the driving force of the conflict and the insurmountable obstacle to any peaceful solution.
Everything else is a series of incidents and counter-incidents of the conflict. Often extremely distressing, they continuously inflame the conflict. But unless the source of the conflict can be addressed and overcome, it will continue indefinitely. This means that ignoring or denying what the Palestinians actually want, and not what advocates of 2-states assume they want or ought to want, is a dangerous evasion.
As a result, the nullification and defeat of the core Palestinian aim is the crucial issue. It is the ONLY hope for a peaceful, safe, and prosperous life for Palestinians and Jews. An end to the illegal and genocidal aim of destroying Israel is the key political solution to the conflict.
The ONLY hope for peace
Specifically, how can the Palestinians be induced to abandon the Palestinian National Charter and jettison the aim of annihilating Israel (I’ve made suggestions for achieving this elsewhere)? This should be the central reform demanded from the PA. Without it, the conflict remains irreconcilable, and a win-win solution is impossible. This guarantees the failure of any supposedly ‘final status’ negotiations.
Of course, goodwill attempts to build personal connections and dialogue with Palestinians may be valuable for certain purposes – such as clarification. But to rely on expectations that those imbued with Arab tribalism and Islamic modes of thought will respond in the same way as those grounded in ‘Western’ cultural values is recklessly improbable.
Recall the shock and dismay expressed by Gershon Baskin and others at the attitudes to October 7 from Palestinians they had known and worked with for years on innumerable ‘peace’ projects.
Relying on zero due-diligence
All this dims into insignificance the search for the common ground desired by the Zoom speakers. It also destroys the simplicity and certainty of the 2-state vision. Yet many who are troubled by Palestinian suffering and mesmerized by the perceived justice of the 2-state solution continue to ignore or deny the reality of Palestinian aims.
Of course, successful denial of Palestinian aims would require ample evidence to the contrary. But where is this evidence? Without it, advocacy of the 2-state solution effectively relies on its absence. This is why simple questions such as those listed above are neither asked nor answered. An additional question that points to the heart of the matter is this:
How can a Palestinian state that intends to destroy Israel possibly produce a peaceful and successful 2-state solution?
Déjà vu politics
The 7th October disaster followed from a badly misguided and mismanaged understanding of the conflict. Adherence to a similarly flawed model threatens further killing sprees. Therefore, the absence of due diligence to test if Palestinian intentions align with the 2-state vision is dangerous blindness. Yet advocates of Palestinian statehood NEVER undertake such due diligence.
Sadly, a certain mindset refuses to grapple with these realities. Both internally and internationally, this severely limits Israel’s ability to formulate or influence policy directions and initiatives needed to navigate this impasse. In fact, there are many political initiatives that Israel could usefully take via the Abraham Accords, the EU, and the UN (which I’ve addressed elsewhere).
Dangerous escalation
For centuries, Muslim Arabs have believed that Muslim Arabs with the power to rule have the right to rule and dominate non-Muslims. Until Palestinians can be detached from these ideas, the expectation that empathy, respect, and understanding will be reciprocated will again disappoint. This strongly suggests that the positive and hopeful ideas for building trust and conciliation, expressed in the Zoom symposium, are less appropriate for conflict resolution and more appropriate for post-conflict healing.
Meanwhile, as long as the Palestinians remain deadly enemies of the existence of Israel, and as long as Israel does not want to be eradicated, these incompatible aims ensure that the conflict will continue. This is because the conflict is not a tragic misunderstanding. Nor is it a territorial dispute that in principle could be solved by a division of land. It is a dispute over the existence of Israel. This is the core reason for the failure of all peace plans and schemes for reconciliation.
Without grasping that this is the nature of the conflict, such fanciful and dangerous ideas as ‘Peace Now’ and ‘Reconciliation Now’ will persist. Consequently, with completely irreconcilable aims, a 2-state ‘solution’ will not be a solution but a dangerous escalation.



